Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.
Table of Contents

GR3

First Iteration Prototype

...

  • When doing searches on Google, users wanted to be able to skim each article, instead of reading them entirely.
  • Users liked that they could see the previous section read. Graying out the previous section was a good idea.
  • Some people would have liked to know where the specific "chunk" of text was, relative to the rest of the article. 
  • Some people expressed frustration that they weren't able to switch to view other pages from the Progress List. This occurred because we did not make a mock-up of every page that Google showed. 
  • When articles chunked immediately, it was not obvious what the page looked like before being chunked.
  • Many people were curious to know what commonly visited pages would look like, such as Wikipedia. 

Second Design Iteration

Improvements based on User Testing

We incorporated the observations from user testing our first iteration (listed in the Observations section above) 

Problem from First Iteration

How it is addressed in Second Iteration

Articles in progress list not clickable

Made articles in progress list clickable so that users can move between articles
they wish to read

Select text icon/functionality non-intuitive

Changed Select Text icon to an Icon that simply had the words "Select Text" on it

Notify the user that the app is in Select Text Mode by adding a text panel on the top of the page
that explains what to do

Don't know where the chunk is located
in the page (context)

Everything else (except the current, previous and next chunk) on the page is visible, but it very
low-contrast and dark - the user can figure out what is going on but does not read those parts of the page.

Hard to learn

Hover over icons for hover-text explanations. First time users prompted to hover over icons for 
instructions and tool-tips.

Need more examples.

Add wikipedia as an example to the prototype

 

 

Additional Points:

  • With adding Wikipedia as an example to the prototype, we were forced to consider what would happen to links the user clicked on in Read/Focus Mode. We added the functionality that links clicked on in Read Mode get added to the Progress List.
  • Links can be added to the Progress List by either right clicking and selecting the "Add to Progress List" option, or Clicking and Dragging a link onto the Progress List. 
  • We changed the name of the Focus button to READ ALL since it is more intuitive

Images of Second Iteration Prototype

We made the changes above and worked on a second iteration.