...
Implementation problems that may have affected the usability of the interface
Toggling of tags for filtering
Indicator of active comments
Persistency of data on server (backend)
Jquery browse load
Evaluation
Setup
Users were found through personal contacts: architect, digital artist, art professor at School of the Museum of Fine Arts. They are representatives of our target populations.
...
- Setup the review process: upload art, select groups of commenters, and categories/tags desired for the review, invite commenters
- Review comments/annotations from commenters; Filter by categories (tags) and by groups
...
Wiki Markup upload button doesn't work \[solved\]
- Make clear which image formats are being supported
Wiki Markup tags page has multiple "submit" and "next" buttons \[solved\]
- make more obvious clear how to enter tags (i.e. comma, space, quote separated) and what they mean , as artists may not be familiar with the concept of tags
Wiki Markup privacy settings page doesn't allow you to drag a group back to being unused \[solved\]
Wiki Markup privacy settings page allows you to drag one group on top of another \[solved\]
Artist view
- maybe have an overlay on the stars that shows the actual numerical rating (e.g. "Average rating: 3.8")
- disable crosshair over art (since it implies that you can add an annotation)
- fix scroll jumping when you toggle filters
Commenter review:
Wiki Markup Empty stars are not very visible \[solved\]
- Give feedback when they rate the piece (e.g. "You have rated this piece 3 stars. Undo?")
Wiki Markup Add feedback/confirmation on deletion \[solved\]
- allow commenters to pin comments that are only in the summary section
- restyle tag buttons so that they actually look like buttons
- Change mouse marker to indicate draggable
- When you have a pending annotation open, cannot close annotation window if you change your mind, and cannot click on an existing annotation to close your pending annotation.
- Expect double click to edit annotation - currently can't edit annotation by clicking on them
...