Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

DACI Decision

Page properties
Status
Status
colourYellow
titleIn progress
Impact
DriverEddy Chen Angelina Costa 
ApproverPranav Bala 
Contributors
Informed
Due date
Outcome

Tips and info

Tip
titleRecommendations

Info
titleContributors

Contributors: I am seeking the right people to get involved in the decision. Add your comments to this page, let's get the conversation started.

Please add:

  • The people directly impacted by this so we can include them.
  • Any references to previous work and investigations that we can leverage.
  • Any constraints and challenges we need to consider to make this decision and following action plan.
Info
titleImpact rating
Expand
titleHow do I determine the "impact" rating of a decision?

Here's an example you can use as a guide.

Decision characteristics
  • The decision will have a material impact on the customer experience OR
  • will significantly impact the roadmap OR
  • will adversely disrupt an internal business process.

Status
colourRed
titleHigh

  • The decision will involve a less than material change to customer experience OR
  • will impact the roadmap OR
  • will impact an existing internal business process

Status
colourYellow
titleMedium

  • All other decisions
Status
colourGreen
titleLow


Background

We need to select a physical layer standard for data communication between Oligo's bus and our payload.

Current state

Data for decision support

Options considered

 


Option 1: Do nothingRS-422Option 2: RS-485Option 3: LVDS

Description


A standard for serial communication allowing a single driver to connect to multiple receivers, using differential signaling for noise immunity.

An upgraded standard of RS-422 allowing for multiple drivers and receivers on a single bus. 

A physical layer specification for high-speed, low-power digital interfaces, often used for video or high-bandwidth data transfer. 

Rollout plan





Pros and cons

(plus) High noise immunity

(plus) Long cable lengths

(plus) Simpler timing that RS-485

(minus) Unidirectional (single driver only)

(minus) Requires 4 wires for full duplex

(minus)

(plus) True multipoint network

(plus) High noise immunity

(plus) Long cable lengths

(minus) Requires software to handle bus turnaround to prevent data collisions

(minus) 

(minus)

(plus) Extremely high data rates

(plus) Very low power consumption (350 mV swings)

(plus) Low EMI

(minus) Point to point

(minus) Requires strict and precise PCB routing

(minus) Shorter cable lengths

Risks





Estimated cost and effort


Cost: Low

Effort: Low

Cost: Low

Effort: Medium/High

Cost: Medium/High

Effort: High

FAQ

Q1.

A1.


References


Expand
RelevanceLink
  









Follow-up action items

  •