Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.
Comment: Migration of unmigrated content due to installation of a new plugin

Excerpt
hiddentrue

Changes in Angular Velocity when the Moment of Inertia is changed, but no torque applied.

Composition Setup

Original artwork and photo by

http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/User:Laretrotienda


Photo courtesy Wikimedia Commons

Excerpt

You can change the orientation of a spacecraft by rotating an internal flywheel

in the direction opposite the direction you want the spacecraft to move. Conservation of angular momentum will guarantee that the ship will rotate in space, without the use of any propellants or changes in the trajectory of the ship. This idea has been used in science fiction for a long time (See Robert A, Heinlein's 1947 novel Rocket Ship Galileo, or his 1959 novel Starship Troopers), and it is being used today on board unmanned satellites. There are several companies manufacturing such Attitude Control Devices. How do they work?

Deck of Cards
idbigdeck

Card
labelPart A

Part A

Assume for simplicity that we can model the Spacecraft as a rod of length D and mass M. The Flywheel is a ring of radius r and mass m. We ignore the masses of the spokes, hub, and motor that effects the rotation of the wheel and Spacecraft relative to each other.

Solution

Toggle Cloak
idsysa1
System:
Cloak
idsysa1

The Spacecraft and the Flywheel are each treated as a .

Toggle Cloak
idinta1
Interactions:
Cloak
idinta1

External influences – none. The ship is in space and the only interactions are internal.

Toggle Cloak
idmoda1
Model:
Cloak
idmoda1

Toggle Cloak
idappa1
Approach:

Cloak
idappa1

Toggle Cloak
iddiaga1
Diagrammatic Representation

Cloak
iddiaga1

As stated above, the Spacecraft is treated as a Rod of length D and mass M. The Flywheel is a ring of radius r and mass m. They are connected by an axis that runs through the Center of Mass of each.

The axis of rotation is perpendicular to the page.

Cloak
diaga1
diaga1

Toggle Cloak
idmatha1
Mathematical Representation

Cloak
idmatha1

The Moment of Inertia of a rod of lenngth D and mass M about its center is:

Latex
\begin{large}\[ I_{\rm rod} = \frac{1}{12}M D^{2} \] \end{large}

The Moment of Inertia of a ring of radius r and mass m is:

Latex
\begin{large}\[ I_{\rm ring} =  m r^{2} \] \end{large}

Conservation of Angular Momentum means that:

Latex
\begin{large}\[ \sum L = L_{\rm rod} + L_{\rm ring} = 0 \] \end{large}

The Angular Momentum L is explicitly given by

Latex
\begin{large}\[ L = I_{\rm rod}\omega_{\rm rod} + I_{\rm ring}\omega_{\rm ring} = 0 \] \end{large}

so the relationship between the angular velocities is:

Latex
\begin{large}\[ \omega_{\rm ring} = - {\omega_{\rm rod}}\frac{I_{\rm rod}}{I_{\rm ring}} \] \end{large}

.

Latex
\begin{large}\[ \omega_{\rm ring} = - {\omega_{\rm rod}}\frac{MD^2}{12mr^2} \] \end{large}

Since M is probably orders of magnitude larger than m, and D is probably orders of magnitude larger than r, the angular velocity of the spacecraft is going to be very small relative to the angular velocity of the flywheel, so the flywheel will have to spin very rapidly to be useful.

Info
titleQuestion

How can you decrease the needed angular velocity of the flywheel in order to produce the same angular velocity in the spacecraft?

Toggle Cloak
idanswer
Answer

Cloak
idanswer

You can increase the mass of the flywheel, or you can increase its moment of inertia

Cloak
answer
answer

Cloak
matha1
matha1

Cloak
appa1
appa1


Card
Part A
Part A

Card
labelPart B

Part B

Solution

What is the Kinetic Energy of the Spacecraft and the Flywheel? We ignore any velocity the combined system may have due to travelling at some velocity, and consider only the rotational Kinetic Energy.

From our expressions for Rotational Energy, we know that this energy is given by

Latex
\begin{large}\[E_{\rm total} = \sum \frac{1}{2} I \omega^2 \]\end{large}


Latex
\begin{large}\[E_{\rm total} = \frac{1}{2}I_{\rm rod}{\omega_{\rm rod}}^2 + \frac{1}{2}I_{\rm ring}{\omega_{\rm ring}}^2 \]\end{large}

Using the expressions for the Moments of Inertia and the relationships between the angular velocities,we get:

Latex
\begin{large}\[ E_{\rm total} = \frac{1}{2}mr^2{\omega_{\rm ring}}^2(1 + \frac{12 m r^2}{M D^2}) \]\end{large}
Warning

There is ZERO Kinetic Energy before the Flywheel starts rotating and ZERO kinetic energy after it has stopped. But while the Flywheel (and the spacecraft) are rotating there very clearly is a nonzero kinetic energy. This is true even though there are no external forces or torques applied. So the kinetic energy of a closed system can be changed purely by internal interactions between the components of a system.

For another example of a closed system with no external torques or forces, in which the Kinetic Energy changes due to interactions between the components of the system, see the worked example called Twirling Skater

Card
Part B
Part B

Deck of Cards
bigdeck
bigdeck