Thanks for all of your hard work on GR2! Below are my notes from grading feedback. Grades should be up soon.
Scenario: Really great scenario.
Preliminary designs: Would have really loved to see you think a bit more outside the box here. Your third design seems to come out of nowhere, but I'd love to see you explore some sort of less-conventional way of displaying/finding information, especially one that's specifically interesting for combo searching. You could also really poke at the input system. Are you sure that the ones you've covered here represent the best ones? You might want to take a bit of paper prototype time to mock up a few other ideas and see if any of them seem better.
A few things to note going forward, for all of the groups:
- Try to make sure your wiki is organized. Don't be afraid to create a table of contents, for instance.
- You may want to refine your scenario for GR3. Note that you're going to be using your scenario to brief your users, so you may want to make it a bit more task-oriented.
- Login and basic account creation are not a good use of your time for prototyping, unless you're planning on doing something really interesting with it. You can assume that basic signup flows work fine.
1 Comment
Katrina Marie Panovich
Hi guys,
Thanks for all of your hard work on GR2! Below are my notes from grading feedback. Grades should be up soon.
Scenario: Really great scenario.
Preliminary designs: Would have really loved to see you think a bit more outside the box here. Your third design seems to come out of nowhere, but I'd love to see you explore some sort of less-conventional way of displaying/finding information, especially one that's specifically interesting for combo searching. You could also really poke at the input system. Are you sure that the ones you've covered here represent the best ones? You might want to take a bit of paper prototype time to mock up a few other ideas and see if any of them seem better.
A few things to note going forward, for all of the groups:
- Try to make sure your wiki is organized. Don't be afraid to create a table of contents, for instance.
- You may want to refine your scenario for GR3. Note that you're going to be using your scenario to brief your users, so you may want to make it a bit more task-oriented.
- Login and basic account creation are not a good use of your time for prototyping, unless you're planning on doing something really interesting with it. You can assume that basic signup flows work fine.
Good luck! Let me know if you have any questions.