In this page you find the spectra, responses and background files necessary to reproduce the spectral analysis in Nevalainen et al., 2010 (A&A, 523, 22) which yielded results summarised in Fig 1.

Fig.1: The average relative difference (diamonds) +- the error of the mean of the fluxes (solid line) and temperatures (dotted line) for different instrument pairs in the soft band (left side of the plot) and in the hard band (right side of the plot)



SASv9.0 was used for processing the XMM-Newton data with calibration information from December 2009 (see details).

XMM-Newton MOS1 and MOS2 spectra and responses are combined and referred to as MOS instrument.

Chandra data are processed with CIAO 4.2. (see details).

For most clusters the Chandra data are obtained with ACIS-S, but for some ACIS-I is used, and marked accordingly.

The script files bestfit....xcm will set up the best fit. In more detail:

  • The scripts use a 1-temperature phabs x mekal model.
  • The column density is from Kalberla et al. (2005) and the absorption cross-sections are from  Balucinska-Church & McCammon (1992).
  • The scripts use the metal abundance table from Grevesse & Sauval (1998).
  • 2. and 3. term in the script file name are the inner and outer radii of the spectrum extraction annulus in arcmin.
  • *hard*, *soft* and *wide* refer to the fits done in 2.0-7.0 keV, 0.5-2.0 keV and 0.5-7.0 keV bands, respectively.
  • *fe* refers to the Fe XXV/XXVI "constr." fit in [6.45 - 7.25]/(1+z) band, i.e. with a prior for the emission measure.

For flux comparison, scale the measured fluxes to the full annulus by dividing with the fraction of the covered full annulus


The following links provide a single tar file for each cluster-instrument combination, containing the spectral analysis material described above:

 

Cluster                                                  Instrument

A1795            XMM-Newton/pn       XMM-Newton/MOS      Chandra/ACIS-S   

A2029            XMM-Newton/pn       XMM-Newton/MOS      Chandra/ACIS-S   

A2052            XMM-Newton/pn       XMM-Newton/MOS       Chandra/ACIS-S

A2199            XMM-Newton/pn       XMM-Newton/MOS       Chandra/ACIS-S

A262             XMM-Newton/pn       XMM-Newton/MOS       Chandra/ACIS-S

A3112            XMM-Newton/pn       XMM-Newton/MOS       Chandra/ACIS-S

A3571            XMM-Newton/pn       XMM-Newton/MOS       Chandra/ACIS-S

A85               XMM-Newton/pn       XMM-Newton/MOS       Chandra/ACIS-I

Coma            XMM-Newton/pn       XMM-Newton/MOS       Chandra/ACIS-I

HydraA           XMM-Newton/pn       XMM-Newton/MOS       Chandra/ACIS-S

MKW3S          XMM-Newton/pn       XMM-Newton/MOS       Chandra/ACIS-I

 

The following links contain some tabulated data from Nevalainen et al., 2010 paper in electronic form.

The first column gives the number X the of the cluster name AX, except for non-Abell names:
Coma = 1111, HydraA = 2222, MKW3S = 3333

Note that for A262 the soft and wide band temperatures are not presented, but instead marked with -999

XMM-Newton pn temperatures obtained within Chandra-driven regions

Chandra ACIS temperatures

XMM-Newton pn, MOS1 and MOS2 wide band temperatures with large XMM-only regions




Attachments

  File Modified
ZIP Archive a1795_pn.tar.gz May 18, 2011 09:50 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a1795_mos.tar.gz May 18, 2011 09:53 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a1795_aciss.tar.gz Jun 20, 2011 07:37 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a2029_aciss.tar.gz Jun 20, 2011 07:41 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a2052_aciss.tar.gz Jun 20, 2011 07:43 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a85_acisi.tar.gz Jun 20, 2011 07:48 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive coma_acisi.tar.gz Jun 20, 2011 07:49 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive hydraa_aciss.tar.gz Jun 20, 2011 07:50 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive mkw3s_acisi.tar.gz Jun 20, 2011 07:51 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a2199_aciss.tar.gz Jun 20, 2011 07:58 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a262_aciss.tar.gz Jun 20, 2011 08:03 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a3112_aciss.tar.gz Jun 20, 2011 08:06 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a3571_aciss.tar.gz Jun 20, 2011 08:08 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
Text File Chandra_data_analysis.txt Jun 21, 2011 10:36 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
JPEG File 15176fg20.jpg Jun 21, 2011 11:00 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a2052_pn.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 03:43 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a2199_pn.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 03:51 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a262_pn.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 03:55 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a3112_pn.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 03:59 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a3571_pn.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 04:03 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a85_pn.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 04:07 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive coma_pn.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 04:11 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive hydraa_pn.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 04:15 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive mkw3s_pn.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 04:18 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a2052_mos.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 04:28 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a2199_mos.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 04:32 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a262_mos.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 04:35 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a3112_mos.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 04:38 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a3571_mos.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 04:44 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a85_mos.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 04:48 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive coma_mos.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 04:52 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive hydraa_mos.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 04:55 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive mkw3s_mos.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 04:58 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a2029_pn.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 09:48 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
ZIP Archive a2029_mos.tar.gz Sep 06, 2011 09:53 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
File t_pn_m1_m2_widereg_wideband.data Dec 07, 2013 09:32 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
File t_pn_acisreg.data Dec 07, 2013 09:32 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net
File t_acis_caldb4.2.data Dec 07, 2013 09:32 by jukka.h.nevalainen_2@touchstonenetwork.net

  • No labels

1 Comment

  1. Unknown User (matteo.guainazzi_1@touchstonenetwork.net)

    1. in principle I would say that the XSPEC scripts should: a) end with a "quit/yes" command; b) produce also automatically spectral plots and list of spectral parameters (via "tclout"). However, I am open to different opinions, and surely the script can be for the time being provided as they are, leaving any functional improvement to a later stage. The current version works fine
    2. I would add to this page some plots, such as the comparison between the temperature and the fluxes in the hard and in the wide band